FOS decisions / Health Insurance
Health Insurance
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
40
Upheld
17
Not upheld
23
Avg redress
£369
Upheld complaints (17)
AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6171421An insurer must act on a valid cancellation request from the policyholder or their authorized representative without unreasonable delay.
UpheldFeb 2026Vitality Health Limited
DRN-6046395Insurers must communicate information to consumers which is clear, fair and not misleading, in compliance with FCA rules and Consumer Duty principles.
UpheldDec 2025ActiveQuote Limited
DRN-5743119An insurer must ensure a policy is suitable for the consumer's demands and needs and provide sufficient information for informed decision-making, particularly regarding pre-existing medical conditions.
UpheldRedress £1,500Switch Health Limited
DRN-5840554An insurance intermediary must ensure a recommended policy is suitable for the consumer's demands and needs, and provide sufficient information to allow the consumer to make an informed decision.
UpheldRedress £225USAY BUSINESS LTD
DRN-5975833An advised sale of insurance must be suitable for the consumer's needs, with clear disclosure of significant differences from their existing cover.
UpheldRedress £950AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6058830The complaint Mrs S complains that AXA PPP Healthcare Limited applied an exclusion retrospectively under her private health insurance policy and declined a claim as a result of this. What happened Mrs S has been represented by Mr S. He call
UpheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-5812553An insurer must handle policy enrollment requests clearly and accurately, providing proper explanation of underwriting terms and conditions before acceptance.
UpheldRedress £200Millennium Insurance Company Limited
DRN-6093597Insurers must act fairly, honestly and professionally in accordance with best interests of customers, and avoid causing foreseeable harm when taking action such as policy cancellation.
UpheldRedress £100AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6134635Insurers must not unreasonably decline claims and must rely on reliable medical evidence, such as endoscopy results, to establish pre-existing conditions.
UpheldRedress £150AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6120142Insurers must handle claims fairly and not unreasonably reject claims; when relying on policy exclusions, the insurer must demonstrate the exclusion applies and show fair, consistent treatment of similarly situated policyholders.
UpheldUSAY BUSINESS LTD
DRN-6115744An insurance provider selling an advised basis policy must ensure it is suitable for the consumer's circumstances and provide sufficient information about coverage limitations.
UpheldRedress £500AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6266571An insurer must apply policy terms consistently and provide clear communication when changing its position on coverage, even when the policy wording itself restricts cover to NICE-approved treatments.
UpheldRedress £100BUPA Insurance Limited
DRN-6089322When claims are received on the same day for related treatment, the excess should be applied fairly based on the chronological order of treatment received rather than invoice receipt order, particularly where this significantly impacts the
UpheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-6164403An insurer must take reasonable care to collect premiums upon policy renewal and notify the customer of payment failures, and must offer fair payment arrangements for arrears caused by its error.
UpheldRedress £400Vitality Health Limited
DRN-6090274An insurer is not responsible for the availability of consultants on its approved list, but must handle cancellations properly and provide reasonable service support.
UpheldRedress £200AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6166368An insurer must handle claims fairly and in accordance with policy terms, which clearly distinguish between counselling (excluded from outpatient limits) and other mental health treatments like CBT (subject to outpatient limits and excess).
UpheldAXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6077954Insurers must provide clear, fair and not misleading information about policy changes at renewal, and must handle claims fairly without unreasonably rejecting them.
Upheld
Not-upheld complaints (23)
AXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6092992An insurer can reasonably decline a claim where the policyholder has exceeded the specified benefit limit, even if the insurer initially approved the treatment.
Not upheldApr 2026Western Provident Association Limited
DRN-6241801The Financial Ombudsman Service lacks jurisdiction to consider discretionary payments made by an employer from their own funds rather than from insured funds under a regulated contract of insurance.
Not upheldFeb 2025AXA Healthcare Limited
DRN-6225537A non-advised insurance sale must provide sufficient information to enable an informed decision, but the insurer is not responsible for suitability if the consumer was given clear information about cover options.
Not upheldExeter Friendly Society Limited
DRN-6222736Under CIDRA 2012, an insurer can apply exclusions for a qualifying misrepresentation if the consumer failed to take reasonable care in disclosing pre-existing medical conditions, provided the insurer would have offered different terms had d
Not upheldExeter Friendly Society Limited
DRN-6165109An insurer may reasonably decline a claim where the treatment location falls outside the policy's hospital list and no contractual exception applies.
Not upheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-6199136A group health insurance provider is not obligated to notify individual members directly of policy cancellation when it communicates administrative matters only with the employer as the policyholder.
Not upheldBUPA Insurance Limited
DRN-6225372An insurance provider is not unreasonably required to approximate treatment costs or proactively ensure a policyholder stays within policy limits; the policyholder bears responsibility for verifying compliance with known limits before commi
Not upheldAXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6204533An insurer may fairly rely on a policy's preventative treatment exclusion to decline claims where the treatment is primarily focused on preventing future disease through health improvement measures.
Not upheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-6098949Insurers must handle claims promptly and fairly without declining claims unreasonably, and compensation for distress caused by delays must be reasonable in proportion to the impact.
Not upheldAXA Healthcare PPP Limited
DRN-6215407Insurance policies covering pregnancy and childbirth are limited to treatment of medical conditions arising during pregnancy, not routine or preventative childbirth procedures.
Not upheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-6094606Private medical insurers may decline claims for treatment provided by specialists outside their approved network, even if the treatment type is covered, provided the policyholder was given clear notice of this requirement and instructions t
Not upheldHeath Crawford Ltd
DRN-6241709An advisor must provide suitable advice based on information actually disclosed by the consumer during the application process, and is entitled to rely on that disclosed information.
Not upheldWestern Provident Association Limited
DRN-6255532Under CIDRA 2012, an insurer may add a retrospective exclusion for a qualifying careless misrepresentation where the consumer failed to disclose material medical investigations within the relevant disclosure period.
Not upheldAviva Insurance Limited
DRN-6257297An insurer may apply chronic condition exclusions under a group private medical insurance policy where treatment requires ongoing monitoring and management, even if the condition has a planned treatment endpoint.
Not upheldAXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6179514An insurer may apply chronic condition exclusions to ongoing treatment that extends beyond the acute phase, provided reasonable notice is given and the policy terms clearly define what constitutes a chronic condition.
Not upheldHowden Life & Health Limited
DRN-6248469An advised insurance sale requires the seller to ensure the recommended policy is suitable for the consumer's circumstances and needs at the time of sale.
Not upheldVitality Health Limited
DRN-5933773Compensation for insurance claim mishandling must be fair and proportionate to the actual impact of the business mistake, not the underlying medical condition or loss of expectation alone.
Not upheldAviva Insurance Limited
DRN-6132217Private medical insurance policies may legitimately exclude cover for chronic conditions as defined in the policy terms, and insurers are entitled to assess claims against those policy definitions.
Not upheldHowden Employee Benefits & Wellbeing Limited
DRN-6060068A financial adviser must conduct business with due skill, care and diligence, provide clear and fair information, and ensure suitability by exploring the customer's medical history.
Not upheldAviva Insurance Limited
DRN-6155608An insurer is entitled to assess claims against its policy definitions of chronic conditions, and a policy exclusion for chronic conditions is a standard and fair term in private medical insurance.
Not upheldAXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6199842A pre-existing condition exclusion clause in a health insurance policy fairly applies where the insured had symptoms of the condition before the policy start date, even if the condition was not then diagnosed.
Not upheldAXA PPP Healthcare Limited
DRN-6127622Private medical insurance policies are designed to cover acute conditions but not chronic conditions, and insurers may impose limitations when a condition meets the contractual definition of chronic.
Not upheldWestern Provident Association Limited
DRN-6204525A moratorium underwriting clause in a private medical insurance policy excludes cover for any condition where symptoms existed before the policy start date, regardless of whether a formal diagnosis was made at that time.
Not upheld